This movie is worth seeing, and probably more than once. We watched this down at the Beaches Cinema yesterday. All three of us thought this was a good movie, although (as usual) I have issues. I had vague thoughts about taking the day off to line up and watch the first showing on Friday, but those never got past the vague thoughts stage. If this were 20 years ago, I would have done it, no question.
The review in the Toronto Star is generally positive.
Here are some of the issues (possible spoiler warnings) --
Delta Vega is fairly close to the energy barrier at the galaxy's edge, not between Earth and Vulcan.
"Red Matter"? WTF? This substance is used to initiate a black hole collapse. It should have been straightforward to insert a reference to dark matter here.
Replacing a planet with an equivalent mass black hole doesn't create an instant "vacuum cleaner" effect.
Most serious - a supernova explosion won't destroy a planet in the way that it is shown to occur.
However, the rationale behind the "reboot" is well done -- it allows therm to acknowledge all of the existing history without necessarily being tied to it.
After the disasters of Star Trek Insurrection and Star Trek Nemesis, this movie franchise needed a good entry to lift it back up - and this movie is it. Star Trek nerds can rejoice.